Sunday, 22 November 2026 South Africa About us
Independent South African journalism
The South African Enquirer Because enquiring minds want to know.
Send us a story Corrections
Opinion

The state must enforce the laws it has written, not plead with courts to do it for us

March and March demands we quit the Refugee Convention and empty Lindela. The state argues detention is lawful. The real test is whether we have the political will to remove those who cannot stay.

Illustration of low angle medium shot of a solitary figure in profile standing before a towering
The South African Enquirer · Illustration

The state must prove it can enforce the laws it has written, rather than outsourcing border control to the courts. When the government cannot remove those who have no claim to be here, the queue at Home Affairs grows and the burden falls on ordinary South Africans.

March and March has made this plain in Pretoria. Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma and her movement are demanding that South Africa withdraw from the 1951 UN Refugee Convention, stop accepting new applications, and order the urgent deportation of detainees at the Lindela Repatriation Centre. Her assessment that 95% of asylum applications are not genuine is a claim about the character of the caseload, not an official Home Affairs statistic. Yet it speaks to the reality residents see: a system overwhelmed by volume, not just backlog.

The legal battle is now in the courts. Judges from the Johannesburg High Court are inspecting Lindela to observe conditions as they consider 33 matters on whether undocumented foreigners expressing an intention to seek asylum must be released automatically. March and March, arguing as friend of the court, says automatic release undermines enforcement and invites abuse. The Department of Home Affairs argues it needs a reasonable period, up to 14 days, to process applications. The UNHCR argues protection begins the moment an intention is expressed.

This is where the state’s capacity is tested. If the law allows detention while applications are processed, the government must have the machinery to process them and the will to deport those who do not qualify. Keeping people at Lindela indefinitely is not enforcement. It is storage. The movement’s demand for court-ordered deportations is a demand for the judiciary to step in where the executive has stalled.

The argument is not merely legal. It is political. Ngobese-Zuma has challenged President Cyril Ramaphosa to prioritise South Africans’ concerns. The people marching in Pretoria are the same people waiting in queues, watching informal trading sites fill, and sending children to overcrowded schools. Their anger is not a fringe complaint. It is the public position on a system that feels out of control.

The court will rule on the law. The government must rule on its own resolve. To build a border that works, the state must first decide it can manage the flow of people without waiting for a judge to tell it how.

Topics immigrationlindelamarch-and-marchasylumborder-enforcementjacinta-ngobese-zuma
Corrections. If something here is wrong, tell us and we will fix it and say so. Write to .