Saturday, 21 November 2026 South Africa About us
Independent South African journalism
The South African Enquirer Because enquiring minds want to know.
Send us a story Corrections
Opinion

A mandate is not a receipt

Cape Town has re-elected its mayor. It has not yet answered the two questions residents will live with: the water and the velodrome.

Illustration of A mandate is not a receipt: Cape Town's water and the velodrome still need answers
The South African Enquirer · Illustration

The Enquirer’s view.

Cape Town has chosen who holds the office. It has not been told what happens to its water. The DA calls Geordin Hill-Lewis’s re-election a renewed mandate and trust. A mandate is permission to govern. It is not a receipt for the two questions this term will be judged on, the city’s water future and the proposed sale of the Bellville Velodrome.

Those questions are not abstract. They reach the tap in your kitchen and the public facility at the end of your road. Water is the thing a household cannot do without, and a velodrome is public ground that belongs to the people who paid for it. On both, the city owes residents an argument in public, not a slogan.

So far the clearest scheduled conversation on either subject is not the city’s. It is a live session the Good Party has announced for Thursday evening on TikTok, where Brett Herron and Cllr Kaden Arguile will discuss Cape Town’s water challenges and the controversy around the sale. That an opposition party is hosting the discussion is not the scandal. The scandal would be if the city let it be the only discussion.

The DA’s fairest defence is that the election was the answer. Voters heard these debates during the campaign, the argument goes, and returned the mayor anyway. Demanding fresh justification now second-guesses the mandate the party describes as renewed trust, and a TikTok live from the opposition is no proof the city has refused to explain itself.

That defence deserves a straight answer, so here it is. An election decides who governs. It does not settle what a specific proposal will do to a specific household. A campaign is a contest of competing claims, and a vote is a judgement between candidates, not a referendum on the fine print of a velodrome sale. The city can honour the mandate and still publish the case for its water plan and its position on the sale, in plain language, with the numbers residents would need to check it. Doing that is not a concession to the opposition. It is what governing with a mandate looks like.

There is a version of this where everyone wins. The city sets out its water plan and the reasoning behind the proposed velodrome sale. The opposition tests it in public. Residents get to weigh in before decisions harden, not after. That is a stronger use of a renewed mandate than treating criticism as ingratitude.

The ordinary reader should care because the cost of getting this wrong lands on them. Water decisions that are explained late or defended thinly are the ones that produce surprises, and surprises in water are paid for at the tap. A public asset sold without a clear public case is a loss nobody voted for. Neither outcome is inevitable. Both become more likely when the only people talking are the ones outside the room.

The city should not wait for Thursday’s broadcast to make its own case. It should make it now, on its own platforms, in its own words, on the record, and take questions. If the answers are good, they will survive the scrutiny. If they are not, residents deserve to know that while there is still time to change course.

Geordin Hill-Lewis has the office and the five years. What he does not yet have is a public account of the water and the velodrome that a resident can read, test and hold him to. The DA should publish that account, and the mayor should answer for it himself.

Topics cape townwatervelodromeaccountabilitylocal government
Corrections. If something here is wrong, tell us and we will fix it and say so. Write to .